Fairway Market

Welcome to Fairway Market, a specialty food grocery located at 50 Manetto Hill Mall in Plainview, NY. This grand old gourmet multi-department store has been a beloved destination for food enthusiasts in Long Island. Fairway Market offers a wide range of high-quality products, including all kinds of fresh produce, specialty items, meats, and vegetables.

Customers rave about the diverse selection of cheeses, gourmet items, and organic products available at Fairway Market. The deli department is known for its robust offerings, while the bakery tantalizes with enticing treats like the Oreo brownie.

One standout feature of Fairway Market is its fair pricing, making it a go-to destination for those seeking quality grocery items without breaking the bank. The store also offers catering services, adding convenience for special occasions.

With a reputation for quality and variety, Fairway Market stands out as a top choice for those looking for specialty foods in the Plainview area. Whether you're in search of fresh produce, prime steaks, or housemade probiotic foods, Fairway Market has you covered.

Experience the exceptional offerings at Fairway Market and indulge in a culinary journey that will leave you coming back for more.

Fairway Market Menu

Location

Address: 50 Manetto Hill Mall Plainview, NY 11803
Phone: (516) 937-5402

🕓 Work Hours
MON 10:00 AM - 09:00 PM
TUE 10:00 AM - 09:00 PM
WED 10:00 AM - 09:00 PM
THU 10:00 AM - 09:00 PM
FRI 10:00 AM - 09:00 PM
SAT 10:00 AM - 09:00 PM
SUN 11:00 AM - 06:00 PM

Business info

  • Offers Delivery
    Yes
  • Accepts Credit Cards
    Yes
  • Accepts Apple Pay
    Yes
  • Offers Catering
    Yes
  • Private Lot Parking
    Yes
  • Bike Parking
    Yes

Last Reviews

  • Author: Tracy K.

    15 July 2020

    Fairway the grand old gourmet multi department specialty store of Long Island in Plainview is saying goodbye. They came in around the millennium and took out Sutton Place Gourmet with volume pricing and a more robust deli department. All kinds of tomatoes, melon, fresh OJ, all kinds of dry goods and well developed specialty departments. An offshoot of their highly successful NYC stores they brought their expertise here. Wow they were where we all went for deli, bagels, produce, amazing everything including organic, fresh pasta, seafood, roasted specialty coffee and the best olive oil selection I've ever seen. An entire aisle for a variety of crisps as my British friend calls them. All kinds of chips, tortilla, potato. Name it. Smoked fish, a whole cheese department with the best Brie you could find. Their own kosher fresh mozzarella which was ok but not Italian hahaha back to the awesome cheeses Like Pierre Robert etc. always loved that one I first sampled here. And of course all kinds of crackers, fig preserves etc etc. the best Babkas brought in from NYC and others from the local Jewish bakery that used to be in the same center. That was a nice way to be a big neighbor. The bakery didn't close because of Fairway. The bakery closed years later because the owner could no longer get help. But they worked well together for years. The associates in coffee were the happiest and most engaging and helpful anywhere. The cashiers got tired and sick of most of us. Hahah. Many there for nearly 20 years. Covid came and went. They hung in and brought produce to Nassau and made it seem like all was fine. It wasn't. They had some associates recover I was told and in another store not as good. They stayed strong and stayed open and somehow there was everything other stores were running out of. Not everything but most things needed. It's with great appreciation I write this last review of Fairway. As I left the store after getting Brooklyn pasta sauce for pennies on the dollar I knew it was the end of en era here. The photos just uploaded show the end. But when it was new and for nearly two decades the memories of the aisles of all kinds of fresh produce and more are what we will all remember. The sign as we left glared brightly Thank You over the exit. I can say on behalf of so many that know and loved this store Thank you Fairway,

  • Author: Martha L.

    08 June 2019

    Surprised I never reviewed this place. I am in here a lot. Love the selections in here. The have a great variety of cheeses, the coffee section smells so good every time I go there it gives me a coffee craving lol. A lot of gourmet items, plenty of organic items and really nice produce. The have some of the nicest staff too! Always a pleasure to shop here.

  • Author: Andrew C.

    11 April 2019

    It's been quite a while since I found myself shopping for specialty grocery items at Fairway Market. Since the opening of new local competitive specialty food stores I have swayed away for lure of somewhere new and the hype of the new specialty store But I came back to Fairway because of the fair pricing for general grocery items, specialty foods, meats & vegetables. And I also find it easier to navigate through this store than their competition.

  • Author: Simon W.

    05 November 2018

    Good market with quality generally a step above the Stop and Shop and Shoprites. I feel Fairway meat, especially the prime steaks are very good and with the sale prices, just great. The bakery has this Oreo brownie that no other fairway has for some reason. I should ask Fairway why that is the case since there is another Fiarway that is closer to me. The seafood counter is always well stocked with fresh fish. The deli counter can be a little wait but the service moves and they always have some samples available to try. There is always enough of the items that are on sale. I buy cases of seltzer which are conveniently available in the front of the store. The aisles here are wide and allow for greater freedom of movement compared to the Fairways closer to the city. Parking is ample and the location is convenient to the I495 for a quick getaway after. Overall a good place to shop for groceries.

People Recommend